Discussion about this post

User's avatar
MD's avatar

"third- and fourth-tier 1970s prog bands"

This is what I've been listening to recently. One reason I'm so convinced your general point is correct is that these days, in occasionally discovering some, by me, overlooked songs from the classic days is that I frequently note to myself: "this random obscure song from 1970 is actually better than any song I've heard from the past 15 years". So case in point, five songs by strictly second-rate bands from that period that easily found their way into my own musical canon.

1970, Forest - 'Bluebell Dance', the production is a bit muddy here, I like the Indian-type(?) modulation in the chorus.

1971, Comus - 'The Herald', this is rather lengthy and the effect is dependent on getting immersed in its mood. But eventually it became addictive.

1971, Trees - 'Murdoch', slightly annoying coda but a folk rock song propelled to greatness by the marching rhythm.

1972, Mellow Candle - 'Heaven Heath', I think it's quite charming and the harpsichord elevates it for me.

1977, England - 'Midnight Madness', pure progressive rock at a time when the genre was past its peak, but it's still "authentic".

I would say this is good as opposed to great music in the sense that I would never trade even a single classic by Pink Floyd or Genesis for these five songs, but I still think that modern music doesn't really have anything of even this quality.

Expand full comment
Robert's avatar

Hi! Today it crossed my mind that we are detached from the artists by playlists. Playlists are the natural evolution of music charts, when you have freedom to pick your own hits and go into the direction you like. Still, you don't acquire the whole artists, you just take a few hits out of their catalog leaving everything behind.

I can see people are becoming playlist-oriented, not giving the albums enough listens or even not interested at all in listening to the whole albums. The computer allows for frantic skipping of tracks and going quickly through them. We abandoned the 70's approach where we had concept albums and suites and I think this was the most important change which shaped Today's music. A while ago you decided to abandon radio - I think we should abandon playlists. Instead, we should try to listen the whole albums and be more focused if we would like to have any connection with the artists.

Expand full comment
17 more comments...

No posts